Rasher said:
MCN in the UK tested all the Adventure bikes a couple of weeks back and got an experienced off-road rider (Enduro chap) to try the Explorer Vs KTM Vs GS (No idea why the excluded the Tenere from this part of the test) on some loose ground (Woods, gravel tracks) and he rated the Triumph very good and better than a GS. They did rate the Yamaha as decent off-road though, pity they did not include it against the others as I would expect it to be second to the KTM.
Overall they rated the bikes:-
1. Explorer
2. Honda Cross-Tourer
3. Ducati MTS
4. BMW GS
5. Yamaha tenere
6. KTM
7. Kawasaki Versys
8. Moto Guzzi Stelvio
The test was mainly on UK roads and most of it on Motorway (Typical of UK bike mags, a romp up and down the M1 is an "Adventure" to them - much further than the normal 50 laps of the nearest race track they base all their opinions on)
The italians didn't exclude the S10 in that part of the test and they came up with...
GS 7 reviewers
S10 1
Xtourer. 1
The explorer they classified as a great GT bike but no one picked it as one they would take home. So just as with the S10 the reviews are all over the place in Rankings.
Yes the poms are scared of dirt, yes the S10 does better when back to back dirt riding is included. (out of the 2). Yes they will all cope with dirt roads. It's just that the KTM will handle the worst best. then the S10 then the GS etc. But if you never leave the tarmac then the S10 is not going to be top of the pops. (as with the KTM)
The KTM is THE bike for big haul crap conditions. I would say that the Honda is going to be the bees knees on tarmac. The rest will fall in between there some where.
It's a pity seeing the KTM low in the rankings all the time as it is a very "targeted" bike. Yes it is way too dirty for most people but it really deserves a bit more respect than the rankings would suggest.
Just as with the 4WD market. In Australia it's pretty much Patrols and Land Cruisers in the Arid regions. By the time you get to the city it's Subaru's and Pradas etc.
Then in the exclusive suburbs it's Porche, BMW, Land Rover. (Land Rover is for the Horsey people).
That's why I hate the rankings system. It is pretty clueless.