Suit yourself, but I can't imagine a few hundred dollars swaying me to buy an AT over a S10 or vice versa. The bikes are so dramatically different, I would think this would overwhelm any small pricing differences. IOW, if you want a heavy, more-comfortable, bigger and much more road-oriented shaft-drive bike with cruise and tubeless, the S10 would be worth paying more. OTOH, if you want a much more basic bike with vastly superior dirt credentials, what with the 21" front end, lighter-weight, and chain, then the AT would be worth paying more for.
I'd also be sure to think about accessories. The Honda ones are very pricey and will be in short supply for awhile. The aftermarket will come on strong, but again, I think it will be awhile and the prices will be very firm. And the rumor is that Honda is only importing a few hundred AT's to Canada in 2016 so unless you're on a dealer list, it might not even be possible to get one this year.
- Mark