Hello 2018S10ES! I am 5'10" and a bit under 200 pounds. I have a Sargent's seat. I rode with the stock seat till it was worn out. Those seats are so personal so to speak so no one can say for sure what will work for you. I have had my seat for a few years now and it is good for me. It is wider than stock and I can run long distances with no issues. However I have removed the back and middle bump stops from under the seat just like I did with the stock seat. Of course I had to make a new part for the latch to hold the back of the seat down correctly after that. I have also moved my bars back towards me so my reach is much better. I personally like a bit harder seat and I have always hated the textured seat top on the original. I do like the Sargent's seat and the only thing that bothers me is mine may be a bit too slick. Depending on what pants I have on I tend to slide a lot during hard braking but all in all it is a very comfortable seat for me. It is wide where I sit and narrow enough in the front I can stand when things get rough. As a matter of fact my legs contact the wide part of the seat when I lean back so I can weight the rear tire and hold my body up with out pulling on the bars. Like I said seats are one of the most personal things on a bike. what works for me may very well not work for you but all the information you can get helps with every decision. Hope this helps you out! Ride smile and have a great day!
Thank you for the info. I’m about the same size of you and I hate the texture of the stock seat as well. Glad to hear the Sargent worked out for you. Doesn’t sound like it takes care of the lean into the tank though without some modification. Been going between the Sargent and Saddleman and I really appreciate the input.