Observations after seeing it at the show

elizilla

Member
2011 Site Supporter
2012 Site Supporter
Joined
Mar 22, 2011
Messages
544
Location
Michigan, USA
This is an excerpt from an email I sent to a friend after seeing the bike at the International Motorcycle Show, back in January. It seemed worthy of posting here, so here goes:

I spent a good long time checking out the Super Tenere. They had two of them there. One was loaded with most of the factory accessory catalog and had the seat in the lowest position, and one was unloaded and had the seat in the highest position.

The Tenere has spoked wheels but the tires are tubeless - the spokes go to flanges instead of going through the rims. The brake rotors are the fancy floral shape like aftermarket rotors on sportbikes. The bike has ABS. Tires are Bridgestones. Based on my V-Strom experiences I would have preferred the Metzeler Tourances - the V-Strom came with Bridgestones too and they just weren't that good. But tires are temporary - no big deal.

The engine is a 1200cc parallel twin, like a bigger version of what's in my TDM. But the Tenere has FI, which will hopefully be less troublesome than the TDM's carbs with their wear-item jets.

Ergonomically it's similar to the TDM, and doesn't feel any heavier. It has a nice narrow feel between my knees, though on the low seat bike, my knees were pushed apart by the bodywork as I had a greater bend in my knees and they pushed forward more. I liked the higher seat better. I could still flat-foot it.

The bars feel a lot like the bars on the V-Strom - both the width and the angle of the grips. The width and the distance forward is fine but I'd like the grips to angle down and back a little bit more. This is a common complaint of mine, though - apparently my perfect wrist angle is different from other people's. Since I might change the bars, I noticed that the tubular handlebars are 7/8" at the ends, where the controls and grips are, but they are larger, maybe 1", where they clamp to the bike. So you'd need some kind of shims, if you change them. The bars are also painted or anodized silver - I wonder how durable the coating will be.

The fairing and windshield look small compared to the NT or even my VFR750. There's a lot of stuff going on, down lower, that makes it wider in front of my knees than the TDM - it's more like the V-Strom there, though the cowling seems to have more stuffed into it instead of being a big hollow shell like the V-Strom. There's a bunch of black plastic wrapped around it, and it's oddly asymetrical - there are vent holes on the left, and swoopy plastic on the right. There appears to be a radiator under those vents. I couldn't figure out was in the right side to balance that. Hopefully nothing too fragile.

The blue metallic paint looked lustrous, with a nice deep clear. Very pretty.

The rear carrier supports seemed to be made of plastic. That's like the NT, where it hasn't given me any trouble, it's been sturdy enough, but I'm still kind of nervous about it.

The headlights look weird. They have a fairly ordinary cats-eye kind of shape, like other bikes, and thank goodness they're symetrical, no bill-the-cat look like on the GS. But they have round shiny orbs inside them; I couldn't see the bulbs in there. Are they HID or LED or something? They didn't look like normal halogen. I haven't investigated this yet but I'm sure google will know.

When I sat on the high-seat bike, my feet were perfectly positioned, not too far forward, not too far back. The footpegs are nice. They have a wide rubber block to put your foot on when your weight is on the seat, that will support your feet well. But the rubber block is soft, and when you stand on the pegs it squishes down and the metal teeth stick up to give you better grip like a dirtbike peg.

The muffler is a big squat high mount thing on the left side only. Maybe people are getting used to this, since I didn't hear nearly as much chatter about how hideous it is, as I heard last year about the new VFR. It seems to be the new style - other bikes in the show were sporting these grotesque pipes too.

The loaded bike had trendy square boxes, and I couldn't tell if they were aluminum or plastic. The salescritter couldn't be convinced to focus long enough to open them and show the insides to me. The left box had a cutout for the muffler. I think if I bought this bike I would not buy those boxes - I'd just find or make a Givi rack. Because I have my doubts about whether those boxes are as rugged as all that, and they are very expensive. I know the Givis are sturdy even when the bike slides down the road on top of them, and that if I need a replacement lid, say, I can get one, and not have to buy a whole replacement Yamaha kit to get the one damaged part.

The loaded bike had a nice bash plate, which I would buy, because the oil filter is in a very vulnerable spot on the front. It also had a big crash bar cage that is likely overkill - the stock bodywork has very stout metal bumpers that would serve as tipover wings. OTOH, with the radiator where it is maybe the crash cage is a good idea. There are some screws right where you'd attach driving lights, that I assume are intended as mount points - I can't see what else they'd be there for. I asked the salescritter and he obviously didn't understand my question - he said "They're crash bars" and gave me a look like I was a moron. I may be a moron, but I know what crash bars are - I wanted to know about the screws. The salescritter didn't figure it out, though, before more men came into his orbit and he no longer had time for mere females. (I was especially amused when he pulled out a bunch of business cards and handed them to all the men standing around me, bypassing me as if I were not there.)

I was a little put off by some quality issues:

1. On the loaded bike, the exhaust pipe was already showing significant rust, in the section where it is buried down behind the motor. The salescritter said it's a stainless pipe but if that's true it's a really poor one. I think that anyone who buys this bike would do well to get the pipes coated by Jet-Hot or someone like that, before they rusted too badly. The unloaded bike didn't have a rusty pipe. I wonder if they ran through a salty puddle with the loaded bike, on their way in or out of a show?

2. On the unloaded bike, there was something crazy going on with the seat. It moved disconcertingly. Perhaps it wasn't attached properly. Or maybe the latches that hold it in the highest position are flimsier? The loaded bike seat didn't rattle and rock like that. Besides the rattling, I noted that the seat was upholstered in the cheapest possible plastic material, barely even qualifying as vinyl, and it was already showing wear near the seams. And the cushioning felt like it would break down quickly. I think this bike will need an aftermarket seat even if the stock seat is comfortable.


My conclusion:
If I hadn't bought the NT last year, or seen the news stories about the Honda Crosstourer, I'd almost certainly be putting down my deposit to get a Super Tenere this year. As it is, though, I think I will wait and see how it does once the bikes are actually in use, and whether Honda makes a Crosstourer. The fact that Yamaha would have show bikes with rusty pipes and tired seats, worries me, and unlike the NT700V, the Tenere is actually a new bike; there isn't a reliability record in Europe to look to. I think I will sit this year out and consider it for 2012. I will definitely be trying to cadge a test ride on one. :)
 

ptfjjj

Making the move from Sport Touring to Adventure
Founding Member
2011 Site Supporter
Joined
Dec 29, 2010
Messages
768
Location
Titusville, FL
A nice, complete, and fair report. Thanks for sharing. There was a report on ADV a while back about a recall regarding the rear carrier, but I'm not sure exactly what it was about. Whatever it was, the problem is supposed to be fixed on current bikes.
 

Ollie

New Member
Founding Member
2011 Site Supporter
2012 Site Supporter
Joined
Dec 1, 2010
Messages
258
Nice write up and observations. Regarding the seat, I wonder how many times those seats have been assaulted by people's rear ends during the bike's demo circuit, over the last several months. I know I must have gotten on and off that thing at least 8 times when I had my chance.

Nice to have a female perspective around here.
 

pqsqac

Bike Name: Blue Spirit
Founding Member
2011 Site Supporter
2012 Site Supporter
2013 Site Supporter
Joined
Jan 19, 2011
Messages
893
Location
Midlothian, VA
Thanks Katherine good report I'd like to hear how they explained a stainless steel pipe rusting? Was it at the header end or along the way back to the muffler? I will check these things out in April when I see the bike. btw welcome to the site. :)
 

elizilla

Member
2011 Site Supporter
2012 Site Supporter
Joined
Mar 22, 2011
Messages
544
Location
Michigan, USA
pqsqac said:
Thanks Katherine good report I'd like to hear how they explained a stainless steel pipe rusting? Was it at the header end or along the way back to the muffler? I will check these things out in April when I see the bike. btw welcome the site. :)
Thanks Vince, glad to be here.

I don't know how they explained the rust - you know how it is at these shows, there are a million people swarming around and getting a salesperson to focus on something like this is hard. And even if you do get their attention, mostly they don't know anyway - they just make things up. You find more info on forums like this.

The rust was at the header end, the area where it's all stuffed up inside and therefore hard to see. But I'm not shy, I will sit right down on the floor and peer into the darkest corners of any bike that interests me. :)

If I had to guess I would say the pipe is probably made of stainless, in the sections that are more exposed. But it perhaps uses something else that has better heat resistance, in the section that's hot and in an enclosed space. Stainless steel may be good for not rusting, but it's not as resilient to other things. There are a lot of kinds of steel with different characteristics. And with all that heat, the rust may not make as much progress as it would down lower, because the moisture gets boiled out better. So it may not be a big deal. My TDM has rusty header pipes but they still haven't holed or weakened, and it's 19 years old.
 

pqsqac

Bike Name: Blue Spirit
Founding Member
2011 Site Supporter
2012 Site Supporter
2013 Site Supporter
Joined
Jan 19, 2011
Messages
893
Location
Midlothian, VA
That's what I plan on doing when I go to Roanoke in April is crawl all over the bike and take lots of pictures plus hopefully get a demo ride. When I saw the bike in DC at the Feb bike show I didn't get to spend much time on it or looking at it. The Yamaha display was the last stop during the show and my group was ready to roll out.


elizilla said:
The rust was at the header end, the area where it's all stuffed up inside and therefore hard to see. But I'm not shy, I will sit right down on the floor and peer into the darkest corners of any bike that interests me. :)
 

colorider

Moderator
Global Moderator
Founding Member
2011 Site Supporter
2012 Site Supporter
2013 Site Supporter
Joined
Sep 25, 2010
Messages
5,442
Location
Sidney, NE
Katherine, thanks for the very informative and well documented review!!!

:)
 

fredz43

Well-Known Member
Founding Member
2011 Site Supporter
2012 Site Supporter
2013 Site Supporter
2014 Site Supporter
Joined
Sep 1, 2010
Messages
3,297
Location
IL, the land of straight, flat, boring roads
Thanks for the report. Perhaps I can volunteer a few observations or opinions to some of your concerns.

elizilla said:
. Tires are Bridgestones. Based on my V-Strom experiences I would have preferred the Metzeler Tourances - the V-Strom came with Bridgestones too and they just weren't that good. The engine is a 1200cc parallel twin, like a bigger version of what's in my TDM. But the Tenere has FI, which will hopefully be less troublesome than the TDM's carbs with their wear-item jets.

I may be wrong, but I believe my son's 2009 650 Strom came with Bridgestone Trailwings. He later switched to Battlewings and likes them much better. The S10 comes with Battlewings.

. Since I might change the bars, I noticed that the tubular handlebars are 7/8" at the ends, where the controls and grips are, but they are larger, maybe 1", where they clamp to the bike. So you'd need some kind of shims, if you change them.

Rather than shims, there are many aftermarket bars of this "tapered" design and you would probably be able to find some to suit you.

There appears to be a radiator under those vents. I couldn't figure out was in the right side to balance that. Hopefully nothing too fragile.

Battery, tool kit, fuse blocks under the right side.

The rear carrier supports seemed to be made of plastic. That's like the NT, where it hasn't given me any trouble, it's been sturdy enough, but I'm still kind of nervous about it.

The only recall on the S10 so far was to strengthen that rack. The display unit we had at our dealer's in January did not have the newer rack and I assume that none of these Euro bikes currently making the rounds of shows did either.

The loaded bike had a nice bash plate, which I would buy, because the oil filter is in a very vulnerable spot on the front. It also had a big crash bar cage that is likely overkill - the stock bodywork has very stout metal bumpers that would serve as tipover wings. I was a little put off by some quality issues:

This bike has been in use in the rest of the world since early last year and feedback on the optional bash plate is that the design can and has lead to damage to the rear sump. Better to get an after market one. Also there are better crash bars that actuallty protect the body work better.

1. On the loaded bike, the exhaust pipe was already showing significant rust, in the section where it is buried down behind the motor. The salescritter said it's a stainless pipe but if that's true it's a really poor one. I think that anyone who buys this bike would do well to get the pipes coated by Jet-Hot or someone like that, before they rusted too badly. The unloaded bike didn't have a rusty pipe. I wonder if they ran through a salty puddle with the loaded bike, on their way in or out of a show?

They are stainless steel and I wonder if what you were looking at wasn't rust, but some remaining Arizona red dust from the USA Press Intro? There are 10 of these bikes in the states and they were all in Arizona late last year for the Press Intro where they were ridden in a lot of that red dust. I know when we had one for display at our dealer in IL in January, I spent the better part of a day cleaning red dust from every nook and cranny and may still have missed some. Still no excuse for a show bike not being thoroughly cleaned, but I would bet that is the case rather than rust. 2.

On the unloaded bike, there was something crazy going on with the seat. It moved disconcertingly. Perhaps it wasn't attached properly. Or maybe the latches that hold it in the highest position are flimsier?

They must have not clicked it into position proplerly. The same latches for low and high position. You only move a plastic support under the seat to another position to raise or lower the seat.

My conclusion:
If I hadn't bought the NT last year, or seen the news stories about the Honda Crosstourer, I'd almost certainly be putting down my deposit to get a Super Tenere this year. As it is, though, I think I will wait and see how it does once the bikes are actually in use, and whether Honda makes a Crosstourer. The fact that Yamaha would have show bikes with rusty pipes and tired seats, worries me, and unlike the NT700V, the Tenere is actually a new bike; there isn't a reliability record in Europe to look to. I think I will sit this year out and consider it for 2012. I will definitely be trying to cadge a test ride on one. :)

As I mentioned earlier, the 2010 models have been in use elsewhere since early 2010. The bikes we get will be 2012 models, so it may be 2013 before the next are available.

Glad you still liked the bike in spite of your misgivings. My replies are in no way criticisms of your comments, merely my attempt to clarify some and I could be wrong on some.

BTW, the NT700 you have is also a very nice bike. Quite a package for someone looking for a good reliable midsize sport touring bike. I have ridden a demo at our local dealer and was impressed.
 

Buckeye56

New Member
Founding Member
2011 Site Supporter
2012 Site Supporter
Joined
Sep 29, 2010
Messages
733
Location
Gahanna, OH USA
Katherine,

Would you be the NT riding lady from Michigan and an acquaintance of Tosh Konya? I am pretty sure we met at the Mail Pouch Fly By last August. My wife has a PC800 and we chatted at length about the NT. Anyway, welcome to the asylum and thanks for your thoughts on the S10!
 

Chadx

New Member
Founding Member
2011 Site Supporter
2012 Site Supporter
Joined
Nov 28, 2010
Messages
331
Location
Bozeman, Montana
Thanks for the good post, Elizilla.

Fred mentioned most of the things that I was going to add.

To be specific on the bars, they are the standard 1 1/8" fatbar size (which all have 7/8" bar ends where the controls are located) so one will have no trouble finding aftermarket bars with a bend that suits each person. No shims needed. I favor Protaper Evos for fatbars, but just about every aftermarket bar manufactures has 5 - 15 different bends of fatbars that will bolt right up to the Super Tenere (though one won't want to drill a hole in aluminum bars for the control alignment. Removing the control's alignment nub is easy, though, and will actually allow for adjusting/rotating the controls to various positions).

Also, I believe the tip over "sliders" are made of polymer. There was a video example of a tip over and he showed them afterwards. As you said, they provided quite a bit of protection for a street slide. Offroad, or on varied terrain, would be another matter so most Super Tenere riders seem to be opting for some form of added side protection, especially with the left side radiator.
 

elizilla

Member
2011 Site Supporter
2012 Site Supporter
Joined
Mar 22, 2011
Messages
544
Location
Michigan, USA
fredz43, the red dust theory makes sense. I was sure wondering how supposedly-stainless pipes could rust! And I'm glad to hear that the seat latches aren't a problem. I continue to not understand how these companies choose to show bikes that are so poorly prepped. Yamaha isn't alone in this - the heated grips on the NT700V that Honda was showing, looked like they were installed by monkeys.

Buckeye56, yes, that was me!

Chadx, I am glad to hear that many aftermarket bars will fit. I've never had a bike with a tapered bar like this - I guess it's a dirtbike thing.
 

fredz43

Well-Known Member
Founding Member
2011 Site Supporter
2012 Site Supporter
2013 Site Supporter
2014 Site Supporter
Joined
Sep 1, 2010
Messages
3,297
Location
IL, the land of straight, flat, boring roads
elizilla said:
And I'm glad to hear that the seat latches aren't a problem. I continue to not understand how these companies choose to show bikes that are so poorly prepped. Yamaha isn't alone in this - the heated grips on the NT700V that Honda was showing, looked like they were installed by monkeys.
As I think about the seat latch, I recall that when we had the display unit on loan at our local dealer's, I had trouble latching the seat when in the higher position. I made a youtube video for the dealer to put on their website (www.niehauscycle.com) and when demonstrating the seat adjustment, I started with it securely latched in the higher position and then showed how to put it in the lower position, as I had no trouble going to the lower position. ;D

As far as prepping the bikes, I know our rep later took the one we had to the Chicago show and I don't know how much cleanup he may have done on it when it got there. If you saw it at the Chicago show, you saw some red dust that I missed when I cleaned it up at Niehaus Cycles. ;)
 

colorider

Moderator
Global Moderator
Founding Member
2011 Site Supporter
2012 Site Supporter
2013 Site Supporter
Joined
Sep 25, 2010
Messages
5,442
Location
Sidney, NE
fredz43 said:
As I think about the seat latch, I recall that when we had the display unit on loan at our local dealer's, I had trouble latching the seat when in the higher position. I made a youtube video for the dealer to put on their website (www.niehauscycle.com) and when demonstrating the seat adjustment, I started with it securely latched in the higher position and then showed how to put it in the lower position, as I had no trouble going to the lower position.
It comes pretty natural after doing it a couple times. The FJR has the same setup and I had problems at first, but not now. Of course, a person does not normally change the seat position that often, once you find your preferred height.
 

JonnyCinco

Ever Dance with the Devil in the Pale Moonlight?
Founding Member
2011 Site Supporter
2012 Site Supporter
2014 Site Supporter
Joined
Sep 7, 2010
Messages
769
Location
Richmond, Vagina
nice write up

"Floral designed brake rotors" = wave brake rotors. Designed to descipate more heat rapidly. i.e. better braking. However, I am amazed that it does not come standard with SS lines.
 

Buckeye56

New Member
Founding Member
2011 Site Supporter
2012 Site Supporter
Joined
Sep 29, 2010
Messages
733
Location
Gahanna, OH USA
elizilla said:
Buckeye56, yes, that was me!
Thought so! Hopefully we will see you on the road this year. We plan to do STAR and The Fly By. River City isn't in the cards this year, too bad as th eIndianna folks put on a nice event.
 

Venture

Administrator
Staff member
Founder
Joined
Feb 26, 2010
Messages
2,126
GrahamD said:
I don't think Japan does SS brake lines do they?
I think the bigger question is what is the true value-add of SS lines? I believe they limit expansion hence providing more precise braking. However, has this expansion coefficient ever truly been measured and shown to be detectable in real-world use?
 

k woo

New Member
Founding Member
2011 Site Supporter
2012 Site Supporter
2014 Site Supporter
Joined
Oct 21, 2010
Messages
300
Location
Eastern North Carolina
My only disappointment after sitting on a Super 10 at the SC IMS was seat comfort. A few reviews have praised seat comfort saying no after-market seat should be needed for all day rides, for me thats 10 - 12 hours. Granted comfort is subjective to who's backside is doing the subjecting and I only sat on it for a few minutes, but the Sergeant seat on my KLR is waayyyyy more backside friendly. Hopefully my mind will change after thorough testing on my S10.
 

doggrell3000

New Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2011
Messages
38
thank you elizilla for your observations on the yamaha super ten . i will be getting a black ( raven ) 2012 super tenere sometime later this year . i also appreciated your heads up on the honda crosstourer concept . i did some googling and came up with a dozen pretty photos of this new bike . i hope honda builds this bike . it has some wonderful technology like the honda vfr1200f 4 cylinder engine which is a 1237cc v4 . it has the more polite honda styling that is a little less mean looking than the yamaha super tenere . the honda crosstourer and the super ten are both beautiful motorcycles yet very distinctive and different designs . the oem honda side cases and top case are attractive . in my humble opinion the honda luggage is better looking than the yamaha oem luggage . i will undoubtedly be thrilled with my super tenere whenever it shows up but i will also keep an eye out for more news about the honda crosstourer . heck - i could easily talk myself into owning both bikes . has anyone heard any more from honda -- i.e. are they going ahead with the crosstourer ? thanks .

doggrell3000
new york ny

honda v4 crosstourer concept adventure bike pictures :

http://www.motorcycle.com/gallery/gallery.php/v/main/news/honda-v4-crosstourer-concept/
 

ptfjjj

Making the move from Sport Touring to Adventure
Founding Member
2011 Site Supporter
Joined
Dec 29, 2010
Messages
768
Location
Titusville, FL
I like the looks of the Honda V4 crosstourer almost as much as I like the look of the S10. Just curious, though; I noticed that the crosstourer has standard forks instead of inverted? I had assumed that inverted forks were better for some reason, but I'm not sure. Does it matter much?
 
Top