Car tire thread for experience -not debate

shrekonwheels

New Member
Joined
Jun 22, 2014
Messages
772
Location
Montana
Re: Car tire?

EricV said:
Please see my previous post. Your opinion is noted, as is your lack of experience and data to back it up. I applaud you for sharing. What's your opinion on colonizing Mars? I imagine you have an equal amount of personal knowledge & experience with that topic. ???
He has a pretty good grasp of what is going on with tires and further posted up the science behind tires which oddly would be pruned, where is the science to back your claims?

As to pruning in general, I was simply content to read thru this thread as I am sure many others lurking would have been to see where it went and to make a decision based on the evidence put forth. Sadly that was not the case, and now it has to be watered down to "Everyone agree or off to the corner" What a boring discussion without any sort of progression which in the end leads to someone making an educated decision, not being TOLD how to think.
 

RIVA

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 9, 2011
Messages
766
Location
Cloyne Co.Cork Eire
Re: Car tire?

2112 said:
Yep, Morgan and they still make them with wooden chassis too. There are a few kit car manufacturers who use bike tyres on very period looking replicas, one of which uses a Guzzi engine and looks very 1930's.
What's this about "Timber Chassis" on cars. What ever next? Timber chassis motorcycles. Never Total sacrilege .
 

EricV

Riding, farkling, riding...
2011 Site Supporter
2012 Site Supporter
2013 Site Supporter
2014 Site Supporter
Joined
May 22, 2011
Messages
8,272
Location
Tupelo, MS
Re: Car tire?

@Andy - I think that's what ChecksWrecks is talking about taking over to the debate area. It's not really adding to the topic, just stirring the pot.

@Fred - while I do use peg weighting techniques in my riding, and did with the CT mounted on the FJR, with equal effectiveness, I don't think "peg stomping" is a valid method for steering a motorcycle, simply something left over from light dirt bike days and poor technique for steet use. Countersteering does turn the bike, and I don't think you're debating that. But hey, I don't "hang off" on the street either.

Much of the problem with this topic is the most strident posters against it, don't actually have any significant experience doing it. Science, um yeah, if you believe any automotive 'expert' has knowledge of using a CT on a motorcycle, you might want to ask them, because they don't. I have yet to meet or speak to one that had done any testing of CTs on Motorcycles, so they lack any real info or experience, just have the same opinion and problems as other detractors, can't see out of the box they are in with only using the 'correct' application.

The point of using a CT, is that no, read that as zero, motorcycle tire manufacturers, offer long life tires that are comparable to the wear we normally expect from a car tire on a car. I got very comparable tread life with the moto application as with a auto application, using the same tire. If there were moto tires that got 40k miles on the rear, this would be a moot subject. That moto users have accepted the BS that 10k, or often less, is acceptable is partly to blame.

What many of you "think" simply doesn't pan out in real world use. I know that, simply because I've actually done it, used the CT on a moto and explored those issues. Cut apart tires after useful life to see if there is sidewall damage, (none), and cut apart tires with sidewall damage from running flat on motos, as well as car tires with sidewall damage from running flat on cars, (pretty much the same damage, a bit less on the moto application, probably just from less weight on the tire).

I'm not "all that" as a rider. I'm decently skilled. Funny thing though, every rider that talks about poor handling on a CT, can't keep up with me in the twisty bits when I'm not even trying to lose them, just riding The Pace and enjoying myself at legal speeds. This is not bragging that I'm such a good rider. It's simply an illustration that the CT is not a limiting factor. Yes, It's different. Yes, you will lose that wonderful thought controlled steering effect of a set of new moto tires and never have that with a CT. And go figure, not all CTs are suitable for moto use. Just as some are better handling than others. To judge a CT experience from one tire on one bike does not give a complete picture. You wouldn't do that from one moto tire and then say all moto tires sucked, would you? You would say the tire sucked, and try another. Yet ever person that ever rode "some friends bike with a CT" always thinks they now know all there is to know. :question:
 

Checkswrecks

Ungenear to broked stuff
Staff member
Global Moderator
2011 Site Supporter
Joined
Mar 7, 2011
Messages
11,506
Location
Damascus, MD
Re: Car tire?

RCinNC said:
Hey, I got snipped!

I don't dispute the snipping, I'm just wondering what I said that was "snip-worthy". I try to avoid being a d-bag on the forums and keep things businesslike, so I'm surprised I violated my own rules.

RC - What got snipped was pretty much anything less than actual usable experience, personal or otherwise. Nothing against you and as I remember you were displaying good logic. Please do re-post whatever you want to over in the other thread in the Debate Room thread which I created and linked to above.


Shrek - For me to have moved those threads or parts of threads would have taken a bunch of time that I just don't have right now. I wouldn't cut a single thing out if we could keep from returning to where we were several years ago when passions and personalities got so pervasive that all we had were ongoing snipe-fests and members quitting. AvGeek and I actually have full time jobs, loved ones, and read every single post in this forum, plus some housekeeping behind the scenes. Now, if you want to maybe increase our pay so we could retire early from those other jobs. . .
O:)


Again guys, this is not an effort to squelch debate or water the place down. I especially like some of those wry little zingers the Brits keep throwing out. Hey, I don't give a care what tire you want to ride and really enjoy watching colorful passionate arguments too. >:D


This was simply to separate uninformed bulls*t and/or mis-use of material (intentional or not) from usable info.
 

Checkswrecks

Ungenear to broked stuff
Staff member
Global Moderator
2011 Site Supporter
Joined
Mar 7, 2011
Messages
11,506
Location
Damascus, MD
Re: Car tire?

I really am impartial about who wants to put what on their motorcycle. I've tried one on a borrowed Wing and I'm sticking to bike tires because they simply roll in and out of turns more smoothly which is basically saying that the MT is the better tool for the job I want the bike to do. When the Heidenau K60 shoulders squared off on my Tenere, it handled FAR worse than the car tire did and had worse traction! My Dad had car tires early on with his Harleys, we have some past Iron Butt competitors in our area, and of course a number of folks here watched both sides of the arguments over on the FJRForum for nearly 10 years.


Again, this thread is about conveying experience and mine was consistent with repeatedly hearing those who have used both types, as summed up in the following quotes from Yellow-Wolf. If you've ever seen videos of a yellow Wing passing sport bikes at Deal's Gap, that's him. Before using car tires Yellow_Wolf was very adamant that car tires should stay on cars and made all the same arguments and sounds that Fred and others have made. However, quoting 'Wolf from after he started to run CTs:


"turns in just a tad harder and needs to be held down in a turn,but this is really minor!!"


"if you want to drag pegs stick with MT"


"better grip coming out of corners,better grip in the rain by far,lasts longer and is cheaper by 100 bucks,,,,yup im never going back,lol"




And in responding to other CT owner's posts (Italics are 'Wolf quoting Trialsman/Glen http://gl1800riders.com/forums/archive/index.php/t-216900.html):


"Trialsman, I totally agree. I've often said the same thing, although not quite as well as you.
For where and how I ride, the car tire is great, and I'll be a Darksider forever. It does everything I ask more smoothly and more safe than a motorcycle tire. However, during the 1 time I had to switch back to my spare MT for a few days I realized that the MT is slightly more natural-feeling in the curves. I think it was you who once said that the MT is like power steering for motorcycles.

I feel that those who say that the C/T is superior to a M/T in every way are drinking the kool-aid and actually doing a dis-service to the Darkside community. The C/T does a great job, handles curves as well as most M/T's, and is safer, quieter, and smoother than a M/T. However, it does require a little adjustment. Not much adjustment, but some.

If all my riding was in the twistys and the bike was my toy to be used only when I wanted, I'd probably use a M/T. In the real world I depend on my bike for daily transportation 95% of the time in all sorts of weather. I feel better and safer on my C/T, and will remain a Darksider.


Glen



well now both of you have said it in a way i wish i could,kudos!"


 

True Grip

Well-Known Member
2013 Site Supporter
2014 Site Supporter
Joined
Sep 11, 2012
Messages
1,574
Location
Centerville,Tn
Re: Car tire?

scott123007 said:
Now, can we start talking about Pilot Road 4's off road? ::012:: :D

I know the outcome of that conversation ;) . Are you going to come to the Hub? I'm in TN if you need a spot to stop over.
 

Checkswrecks

Ungenear to broked stuff
Staff member
Global Moderator
2011 Site Supporter
Joined
Mar 7, 2011
Messages
11,506
Location
Damascus, MD
Re: Car tire?

scott123007 said:
Now, can we start talking about Pilot Road 4's off road? ::012:: :D
Scott - You sir already proved that could be done!
::001::
 

True Grip

Well-Known Member
2013 Site Supporter
2014 Site Supporter
Joined
Sep 11, 2012
Messages
1,574
Location
Centerville,Tn
Re: Car tire?

Checkswrecks said:
Scott - You sir already proved that could be done!
::001::
Scott was on his PR4's in Arkansas and came thur WFO Petes "Rock Hop" unscathed. I couldn't with my TKCs :-[
 

stomp347

Member
Joined
Aug 4, 2014
Messages
288
Location
Conn
Re: Car tire?

True Grip said:
Scott was on his PR4's in Arkansas and came thur WFO Petes "Rock Hop" unscathed. I couldn't with my TKCs :-[
LOL...I would assume Scott had a CR125 while growing up and had to pin it through the knarly stuff!! ::015::
 

loftybob

Active Member
Joined
Jul 23, 2015
Messages
146
Location
Australia
Re: Car tire?

I have been running car tyres for over 100,000 Km's on my high performance Triumph Rocket 111's



With over 280 RWHP, there is no bike tyre that can handle the power and torque these monsters can throw out.

A lot more grip in the wet, 25-30,000 Km's tyre life, and did I mention the grip.

Still alive, and can hold my own in the twists.

Regards Lofty
 

loftybob

Active Member
Joined
Jul 23, 2015
Messages
146
Location
Australia
Re: Car tire?

Rode around Australia with this one, two up towing a camper trailer.

This was a run flat tyre, that looked like new after doing 15,500 Km's.

 

RIVA

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 9, 2011
Messages
766
Location
Cloyne Co.Cork Eire
Re: Car tire?

loftybob said:
I have been running car tyres for over 100,000 Km's on my high performance Triumph Rocket 111's



With over 280 RWHP, there is no bike tyre that can handle the power and torque these monsters can throw out.

A lot more grip in the wet, 25-30,000 Km's tyre life, and did I mention the grip.

Still alive, and can hold my own in the twists.


Regards Lofty

It would be interesting to know what make of car tyre your high performance Triumph Rocket 111 came shod with, from The Triumph assembly line. Pleas tell :D
 

Checkswrecks

Ungenear to broked stuff
Staff member
Global Moderator
2011 Site Supporter
Joined
Mar 7, 2011
Messages
11,506
Location
Damascus, MD
Re: Car tire?

LoftyBob, I'd forgotten that a guy here in town switched his Rocket to a car tire. I rode it both before and after and honestly can't say that I noticed much difference. I do know that he had to play with it for a while to find a pressure he liked before I rode the CT months later.


Wow, I just went to the Triumph site and can see why there'd be little change in feel. Even the OEM Triumph tire is a 240/50, which would more typically be a car profile.
 

Dogdaze

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 17, 2014
Messages
3,040
Location
Solothurn, Switzerland
Re: Car tire?

CW. where have you been lately? The big VZR1800, Victory Hammers and a few others all run 240 now, but, still a MC tyre with a round profile.........
My old bike with a 210
 

Attachments

Checkswrecks

Ungenear to broked stuff
Staff member
Global Moderator
2011 Site Supporter
Joined
Mar 7, 2011
Messages
11,506
Location
Damascus, MD
Re: Car tire?

I was responding more from the thought of having forgotten riding his Rocket, as it sure is not a ride easily forgotten.


Seriously for a second and while this is not CT vs MT, it's to keep usable info in this thread separate from the debate thread. Cars with very low profile tires are the cool look among the kids and most of us have those, so what follows is about choice in tires.


When it comes to the "very low-profile" tires on cars, I do know of accidents and people getting killed. We were just looking at one of these from an SUV a few weeks ago. The very low profile tires are MUCH more critical as far as pressure and vulnerable to road damage. Example photo off the web:


 

Checkswrecks

Ungenear to broked stuff
Staff member
Global Moderator
2011 Site Supporter
Joined
Mar 7, 2011
Messages
11,506
Location
Damascus, MD
Re: Car tire?

The Rocket3 is an impressive bike, but as a favor, would you guys mind moving this to the Other Bikes area? Create a thread and we can move these posts so they don't get lost.
Thanks

Later - Never mind - A new thread started is now in Other Bikes for the Rocket 3 and the non-CT posts from here have been moved to that thread.
 
Top