BMW GS Update

bmac

Active Member
Joined
Mar 17, 2012
Messages
284
Location
Florida, Wisconsin
Well, I drank the Koolaid about a month ago. IMO:

Super Tenere: Clutch engagement point more centered in range, friction zone larger, brakes better, first gear feels more linear, shifting seems smoother. Less stuff to go wrong.

1250 GSA: engine noticeably smoother with more hp and torque, switchable ABS, better dash and electronics, ride modes tunable and noticeably different characteristics switching between them. Mine came with hard luggage (and racks), heated grips, aux lights, crash bars, skid plate, and nav prep - all of which I had to add a la carte to my ST.

I've been enjoying both for the last month, but it's time to let the ST go, only because the 2 are so matched in size and mission that it seems redundant to have both. I might keep 2 bikes, but if one's a big ADV bike, the other will NOT be.

The ST is fully dialed in for me and I have lots of happy memories with it. It never disappointed me or stranded me. In times when things could have gone south, I was always presently surprised by its durability and capability. I realize I'm one big BMW reliability issue away from regret, but I'm having my YOLO German bike for now.
Congrats on the bike. Hopefully, yours will be as good to you as mine has been to me.
 

steve68steve

Active Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2014
Messages
441
Location
Seacoast, NH
But, and it's a Kardashian sized but. . . . I just can't trust the bike. With Yamaha, and to be honest. . . . any of the brands from Japan, I know that I will likely not have any issues with them. I just don't have the same faith with BMW. (from personal experience, not hearsay)

As a kinda weird comparison: One of the new Corvettes is $75k-ish. A new Porsche 911-Turbo (not the turbo-S) is $175k. The 911 claims to have more horsepower, and is about .5 seconds quicker to 60mph. Now, neither of these cars are my style, but. . . . being able to buy two 'Vettes for the price of one 911? That's a shit ton of extra money. . . . for what? I don't know Porsche's reliability record, but, I do know that their services are quite expensive. Also, I don't know where the nearest Porsche dealer is. But, I do know where three Chevy dealerships are. I'm not talking bad about the Porsche, I just want to know what that astronomical price gives me.

Everybody has their priorities, and that fine. Mine is bang for the buck. I'm not going to pay more for something, if I'm not going to get more of that something in return.
It's fine that you don't trust it, but that's a different thing than thinking there's no difference to justify the higher price of the BMW.

If you don't want to pay more for something, why don't you trade your ST in for a KLR?

Because an ST has shaft drive, ABS, ride modes, cruise control, more than 2x the hp, a freakin' gas gage and clock, and on an on. You can't buy a KLR with the same features as the ST. Does that mean the ST is "not worth it?"

You can't buy an ST with all the stuff that's standard on the BMW. That doesn't mean the BMW is a better or more reliable bike, or worth it to you. It just means you're conflating your lack of trust with lack of value.
 

Sierra1

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2016
Messages
14,968
Location
Joshua TX
. . . . You can't buy an ST with all the stuff that's standard on the BMW. That doesn't mean the BMW is a better or more reliable bike, or worth it to you. It just means you're conflating your lack of trust with lack of value.
You may be absolutely correct. If all the extra bells & whistles on the Beemer, that are not even available on the Yamaha, are what a person wants/needs, then you are correct, and the Beemer is the only choice. I'm not a bells & whistles kinda guy though. But, I am a reliability kinda guy, so the Yamaha was my only choice.
 

steve68steve

Active Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2014
Messages
441
Location
Seacoast, NH
You may be absolutely correct. If all the extra bells & whistles on the Beemer, that are not even available on the Yamaha, are what a person wants/needs, then you are correct, and the Beemer is the only choice. I'm not a bells & whistles kinda guy though. But, I am a reliability kinda guy, so the Yamaha was my only choice.
Mine, too. I have both.
 

Madhatter

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2013
Messages
3,858
Location
buda texas
so a friend and me stopped by the local multi brand dealer ,and like a moth to a flame I'm drawn to the BMW 1250 gs ...... I really need to ride one or rent one or something . put 120 miles on my Tenere yesterday , felt pretty good .
 

PhilPhilippines

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2020
Messages
952
Location
Philippines
so a friend and me stopped by the local multi brand dealer ,and like a moth to a flame I'm drawn to the BMW 1250 gs ...... I really need to ride one or rent one or something . put 120 miles on my Tenere yesterday , felt pretty good .
It will be great I am sure. It is designed to be. It's the flaws that aren't...and they are either there in the course of time, or not...

NB: Just re-read my post. What Sierra1 said :D
 

Madhatter

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2013
Messages
3,858
Location
buda texas
in 11 days I leave for Colorado .will probably do close to 3 k miles . if I'm not loving this bike by my return who knows what I might do. the gps says from here to there is 932 miles so round trip is 1800 + miles . and 3 days in FairPlay , will do loop rides from there about 300 miles a day (maybe ) so I can see an easy 2700 mile trip . I just need seat time . and maybe a ride on a GS.
 

Madhatter

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2013
Messages
3,858
Location
buda texas
weird Texas weather and my new mustang conspire to keep me off the Tenere . and the beta on weekends is in cahoots with them too. poor Tenere is not feeling the love.
 

bmac

Active Member
Joined
Mar 17, 2012
Messages
284
Location
Florida, Wisconsin
weird Texas weather and my new mustang conspire to keep me off the Tenere . and the beta on weekends is in cahoots with them too. poor Tenere is not feeling the love.
It is tough to choose the motorcycle during a hot summer when you have a fantastic performance car with AIR CONDITIONING!
 

Dirt_Dad

Well-Known Member
Founding Member
2011 Site Supporter
2013 Site Supporter
2014 Site Supporter
Joined
Sep 21, 2010
Messages
5,973
Location
Northern Virginia, USA
It is tough to choose the motorcycle during a hot summer when you have a fantastic performance car with AIR CONDITIONING!
I see you've typed letters in some specific order, but I don't have any idea how to interpret them?

Car over motorcycle?...as a choice?...for enjoyment?... I'm sure I'm misunderstanding something. Turning to Google Translate....
 
Top